A New York appeals court has overturned the aggravated driving while intoxicated conviction of a Vermont woman arrested after a fatal crash in upstate New York.

The Appellate Division’s decision means Cassie Earley, 30, of Arlington, Vermont, won’t have to serve a one-year jail sentence for the July 2012 crash in Hebron that killed 83-year-old Vincent Muro Sr. of West Rutland, Vermont, the Glens Falls Post Star reports.